Indeed, certain judges argued V-8s had no place in this year’s competition. Their arguments held water in the fall when the average price of a gallon of regular unleaded across the U.S. was $3.86.
But by the time our evaluations were done at the end of November, fuel prices had fallen off a cliff, to a much more palatable $1.79 a gallon, capping a frenetic swing that tested family budgets, changed vehicle purchase decisions and altered the national psyche.
Even with expensive fuel, a number of Ward’s judges would have gone to the mat to place Chrysler LLC’s all-new 5.7L OHV Hemi V-8 on this year’s 10 Best Engines list. It is enormously satisfying, thoroughly entertaining and absolutely engaging in the two newest and most disparate applications we tested: the 390-hp Ram pickup and 376-hp Challenger R/T coupe.
The Hemi earns the honor not on pure emotion or brute force but with advanced new technology such as variable valve timing, which allows cruising in 4-cyl. mode about 40% of the time, twice as much as the previous-generation Multi-Displacement System cylinder-deactivation system. Thanks to this bit of engineering wizardry, the new Ram can cruise in 4-cyl. mode up to 70 mph (112 km/h), 10 mph (16 km/h) faster than the previous truck.
A number of Ward’s testers managed to top 19 mpg (12.3 L/100 km) with the Hemi, putting it in line with certain premium V-6s tested.
And the new active air intake manifold cracks open a whole new realm of performance for the Hemi. During normal driving, butterfly valves in the circular intake runners remain closed, allowing air to follow a lazy path to the combustion chamber.
But under hard acceleration, at about 4,000 rpm, the valves open, cutting in half the length of the intake runner and ramming more air into the engine. The effect is a potent kick in the tail, as if a turbocharger were kicking in.
The new Hemi does more work north of 4,000 rpm than it ever did before – and manages to do so without feeling taxed or winded. A sprint to 60 mph (96 km/h) in a Crew Cab Ram in less than 6 seconds is no small feat.
All the while, the Hemi lets out a glorious exhaust note that pushes buttons for every red-blooded American, especially in the Challenger.
“Can’t think of one thing I disliked,” judge Byron Pope raves after his night in the Hemi-powered Challenger.
Chrysler expects 65% of new Ram buyers to pick the Hemi V-8. The auto maker told us that in August when a trip to Citgo in a V-8 pickup cost upwards of $75, so a higher Hemi take rate is not out of the question.
For now, Chrysler doesn’t have the marketing budget to support the Hemi as it did to great effect when the previous-generation Hemi launched in 2002.
Regardless of fuel prices, there will be a place on the 10 Best Engines list for modern, fuel-efficient V-8s such as the Hemi as long as OEMs keep making them and as long as someone needs them, doggonit.
5) Ford Motor Co.: 2.5L DOHC I-4 HEV
Placing a hybrid-electric vehicle on the 10 Best Engines list is always a charged affair.
Only three auto makers have managed to crack the list this decade, amid questions from internal-combustion purists who want this competition to be only about engines, not tag-team systems that need electric motors.
This year, a fourth OEM joins that short list as Ford Motor Co. collects a trophy for its second-generation Escape Hybrid cross/utility vehicle, which benefits in no small measure from Ford’s all-new 2.5L DOHC I-4. The engine replaces the less capable 2.3L I-4 in the first-generation HEV.
With intake variable camshaft timing, the new 4-cyl. delivers a broader power band and operates on the Atkinson combustion cycle (similar to most other hybrids), which improves efficiency up to 10% over conventional Otto-cycle configurations by keeping the intake valves open longer.
This reduces the engine’s pumping losses by allowing a small portion of the fuel/air charge to flow back into the intake.
Mechanical changes include new intake and exhaust manifolds; a new intake camshaft; and higher-compression pistons (12.3:1) vs. the non-hybrid I-4 (9.7:1). The previous generation’s nickel-metal-hydride battery, continuously variable transmission and electric motor carry over to the new hybrid.
Most of these changes are indiscernible to the driver, but a smart new engine controller allows the driver to rapidly identify the considerable gains achieved by the new Escape Hybrid.
The new processor allows for smoother transitions between gas and electric mode and more EV-mode driving. The old Escape Hybrid might make it to 30 mph (48 km/h) on electricity, alone, but tuning refinements enable the new 5-passenger CUV to hit 40 mph (64 km/h) without consuming a drop of gasoline.
The same hybrid configuration also is available in the Escape’s platform mate, the Mercury Mariner.
Make no mistake, the Escape Hybrid is not a “performance hybrid” with whopping torque and high horsepower. Instead, this vehicle is all about great fuel economy.
We’ve tested too many hybrids that have failed to meet their federal mileage expectations, but not the new front-wheel-drive Escape Hybrid, which is rated at 34/31 mpg city/highway (6.9-7.5 L/100 km).
Even without extreme “hyper-mile” driving tactics, meeting and surpassing those numbers is not difficult. One Ward’s judge managed 39 mpg (6 L/100 km) in a mixed driving cycle and a staggering 46 mpg (5.1 L/100 km) in mostly city driving, without inciting road rage among other motorists who prefer to be ahead of poky drivers.
General Motors Corp.’s 2-mode hybrid in the GMC Yukon earned a 10 Best Engines award in 2008, but this year’s standard-bearer among hybrids is the ’09 Escape, which is about half the price and capable of twice the fuel economy, while still being a remarkably roomy and functional CUV.
6) General Motors Corp.: 3.6L DOHC V-6
Republican U.S. senators who see nothing but failure when considering a government loan to General Motors Corp. clearly know nothing about engines.
If they did, they would give GM the props it deserves for engineering, manufacturing and selling a stellar direct-injection gasoline DOHC V-6 that rivals the world’s finest 6-cyl. engines.
For the second straight year, the 304-hp 3.6L “high-feature” V-6, which first appeared in the Cadillac CTS, finds itself on the Ward’s 10 Best Engines list for its dazzling throttle response, competitive fuel economy, laudable low-end torque, impressive specific output (84 hp/L) and effortless power delivery.
And once again, this V-6 continues to run on regular unleaded fuel, which most engines of this caliber are not designed to do. When gas prices rise again, which they inevitably will, this factor, alone, is bound to clinch a few sales in GM showrooms.
This V-6 is a perfect fit for Cadillac, proving that a quiet idle and smooth, everyday cruising can go hand-in-hand with a throaty exhaust note and neck-snapping torque at just about any engine speed.
Premium 6-cyl. engines have been fierce combatants every year in our perennial evaluation of powertrain excellence. This year, the GM V-6 makes the cut, alongside Honda Motor Co. Ltd.’s 3.5L V-6 in the Accord, BMW AG’s turbocharged 3.0L I-6 in the 135i coupe and Toyota Motor Corp.’s 3.5L V-6 in the Lexus IS 350.
They’re all great engines, but GM will top them most of them in ramping up production of the 3.6L V-6 to power the high-volume Lambda-platform cross/utility vehicles, including the new Chevrolet Traverse, Buick Enclave and Saturn Outlook. It also will be the base engine in the new Chevrolet Camaro.
By 2010, GM says it will offer 18 models with DIG in North America, more than any other auto maker. Next summer, the ’10 Chevrolet Equinox CUV goes on sale with a choice of two new fuel-saving DI engines, a 2.4L I-4 and a 3.0L V-6, both of them eligible for 2010 Best Engines testing.
Derived from the 3.6L award-winner in the CTS, the 3.0L V-6 is rated at 255 hp and 214 lb.-ft. (290 Nm) of torque. The Equinox debuts at January’s North American International Auto Show in Detroit.
Smartly, GM is betting big on DIG as a way to boost power and improve fuel economy and emissions. While critics suggest GM lags its competitors in embracing new technology, the 3.6L V-6 proves otherwise, already employing direct injection even though some competitors have yet to take the technology into production.
The 3.6L carries over its variable valve timing and phasing system on both intake and exhaust valves. New electronic controls improve the engine-management system and fuel-injection operation, while considerable effort has been paid to improving NVH characteristics, a trait that was praised last year.
Ward’s Dealer Business Editor Steve Finlay credits the V-6 in the CTS for “amazing performance. With engines like this, who really needs a V-8?”
If any gearheads win election to the Senate, maybe they’ll ask the same question.
7) Honda Motor Co. Ltd.: 3.5L SOHC V-6
The word “rocket ship” is rarely proffered on behalf of the Honda Accord, a fine car, to be sure, but known for reliability and practicality rather than sweaty-palm titillation.
Yet, more than one 10 Best Engines judge used that term to describe the 3.5L SOHC V-6 that powers the Accord coupe to its second consecutive 10 Best Engines award.
This 271-hp V-6 does so many things well. Its steady road manners might lull the driver into thinking this powerplant is sedate and timid.
But crack open the razor sharp throttle at any speed, and this engine, with Honda’s typical understated excellence, springs to life like a tiger hiding in the brush, pouncing on a hapless antelope.
This engineering masterpiece remains amazingly composed, even at the 6,800-rpm redline, without a hint of torque-steer in the front-wheel-drive Accord.
Channeling this power is a magnificently smooth-shifting 6-speed manual that cycles through every gear as if in complete harmony with the vehicle. The 1-2 shift satisfies with an ease and confidence unmatched by any production 3-pedal V-6.
The only reason for a buyer to bypass the manual is because Honda’s nifty 3-stage Variable Cylinder Management cylinder-deactivation system is limited to automatic-equipped Accords.
While most V-8s with cylinder deactivation can cut off fuel to half the combustion chambers, Honda’s system allows the 3.5L V-6 to function on six, four or three cylinders, depending on engine loads, saving even more fuel and creating a new level of performance.
Ward’s evaluated only the manual Accord for 10 Best Engines, which is no consolation prize, given the fatter power curve. Even without VCM, several judges managed 21 mpg (11.1 L/100 km) in spirited driving, better than other premium V-6s tested.
Honda’s 3.5L V-6 scores extra points for also being incredibly versatile, appearing in the Honda Odyssey minivan, Ridgeline pickup and Pilot cross/utility vehicle, as well as Acura luxury cars. Honda produces nearly all those engines in high volume at its plant in Anna, OH.
Ward’s judges eagerly heap praise on the Accord V-6.
“Plenty of power on hand,” writes Associate Editor Byron Pope on his score sheet. “I didn’t expect this much power in an Accord. Very impressive.”
Editor Drew Winter says the Honda powerplant “somehow seems faster and better than last year.”
A V-6 this good belongs in a car priced well above $30,000, but the Accord coupe can be had for $28,805.
This package totally speaks to the enthusiast buyer who wants practicality most of the time, but superior performance all of the time.
8) Hyundai Motor Co. Ltd.: 4.6L DOHC V-8
It’s a bold move by Hyundai Motor Co. Ltd. to roll out a new V-8 in a time of economic downturn and fuel conservation.
Yet, the new Tau 4.6L DOHC V-8 scores a first-time Ward’s 10 Best Engines appearance for the South Korean auto maker with an impressive mix of power, efficiency and affordability.
Unanimously praised for being a ton of engine for the V-8 Genesis sedan’s sub-$40,000 asking price, the Tau represents Hyundai’s longing to undercut the price of established luxury-vehicle players, while also flexing its engineering muscle.
With high levels of refinement permitting creamy runs up the powerband, the Hyundai V-8 feels much like the 4.6L Toyota Motor Corp. and General Motors Corp. Northstar V-8s that influenced its design.
However, variable intake and valvetrain systems, as well as other advances in internal components, allow the 375-hp Tau to outperform all of its mid-level luxury rivals, including in the area of fuel economy.
And most of those rivals, namely from BMW, Mercedes-Benz and Lexus, are considerably more expensive than the $54,000 price cap afforded to 10 Best Engines entrants.
In real-world driving, fuel economy approached a respectable 20 mpg (11.8 L/100 km) and the rear-wheel-drive Genesis never lacks passing power.
Performance is not blistering, though, and the Tau does not behave as if it wants to break free from its computer-controlled leash, leading some judges to criticize it as a “me too” engine created just for the sake of slapping a V-8 badge on the back of the car.
Indeed, the Tau makes little effort to forge a bond with the driver, preferring to go about its business of whirring away quietly under the hood.
Despite being a little short on emotion, the Tau is an engineering triumph for an auto maker venturing for the first time into the luxury market.
While some quibble that a supercharged or turbocharged version of Hyundai’s already solid 3.8L V-6 would perform just as well as a V-8, the auto maker is quick to point out it has greater things in store for the Tau.
Hyundai says the engine’s 6,500-rpm redline is adequate for the Genesis, yet it has the potential to spin up to 7,200 rpm. It also is compatible with direct-gasoline injection, cylinder deactivation, variable-valve lifting and forced induction, features the auto maker says will enter production in the near term to keep the Tau relevant.
Such forward thinking is commendable, especially considering Hyundai’s rapid ascension of the automotive hierarchy.
The timing for the Tau’s introduction could have been better, but it works beautifully in its Genesis application. It also has the built-in potential to improve over time and is hard to fault in terms of overall performance, fuel economy and price.
Now that’s 10 Best Engines material.
9) Toyota Motor Corp.: 3.5L DOHC V-6
Laying claim to its fourth-consecutive slot on the Ward’s 10 Best Engines roster, Toyota Motor Corp.’s 3.5L Lexus V-6 once again emerges as the engine to beat among a field of excellent V-6 competitors.
With a delectable balance of power, grace and technology, the engine powering the Lexus IS 350 is a favorite of several judges and impresses all with its class-leading horsepower, torque and fuel economy.
Not much can be said about this engine without directing attention to its unique fuel-injection system, comprised of separate port- and direct-gasoline-injection circuits.
Criticized by some judges as an over-engineered, “belt-and-suspenders” approach, the dual-stage fuel system improves all-around performance by taking advantage of the strengths of each technology.
Nissan Motor Co. Ltd.’s larger VQ 3.7L DOHC V-6, for example, easily trumps the Lexus in top-end power without DIG, yet trails it in terms of torque output and observed fuel economy.
Even Honda Motor Co. Ltd.’s 3.5L SOHC V-6 and General Motors Corp.’s 3.6L DOHC V-6, both of which make a return to 10 Best Engines status, lag the Toyota mill in overall flexibility and outright power delivery.
However, unlike the GM V-6, which frugally burns regular unleaded, the Lexus’ high 11.8:1 compression ratio necessitates the use of premium fuel. And for all its DIG-infused torque, horsepower peaks at a relatively high 6,400 rpm.
Fortunately, the engine loves to rev to its redline and feels honed to near perfection in the process.
As noted last year, Toyota is making baby-step headway in infusing its products with a more-passionate connection to the driver. We find this Lexus variant of the Toyota 3.5L DOHC V-6 to be one of the best examples of that focus, particularly with the sweet-sounding optional sport exhaust.
Yet, not all are enamored by the melodies emanating from the car’s twin oversized tailpipes. While some judges favor the mechanically precise wail at full throttle, others find it to be droning and too loud at low speeds.
Regardless, this engine portends the auto maker’s eventual shift to DIG engines and provides its Lexus brand with a shot of vigor that is missing from other Toyota vehicles.
Although two impressive V-8s made this year’s list, high-output 6-cyls. such as this make it clear that a solid V-6 will continue to grow in importance as the keystone in many premium-powertrain game plans.
10) Volkswagen AG: 2.0L SOHC I-4 Turbodiesel
The last time an affordable diesel landed on the Ward’s 10 Best Engines list, in 1997, a gallon of regular unleaded cost less than $1.25 and Americans were discovering the functionality of gas-guzzling SUVs and personal-use pickups.
At the time, diesels were as relevant as hybrids, which hadn’t even arrived yet in the U.S. True, VW diesels of the day were capable of 45 mpg (5.2 L/100 km) when the Toyota Prius was just starting production in Japan.
But consumers cared little about fuel economy, and that VW turbodiesel belched smoke during startup, although it was deliciously torquey.
Today, a modern, high-pressure common-rail European turbodiesel from VW sets a new standard with the all-new 2.0L SOHC I-4 that wins a 10 Best Engines award in its first year of eligibility.
Plus, the spunky-yet-quiet I-4 breaks new ground by meeting the strict Tier 2 Bin 5 emissions standard without expensive (and inconvenient) urea-injection aftertreatment, which is necessary for larger diesels. Instead, oxidation catalysts and regenerating particulate filters do the job, allowing the all-new Jetta TDI to be sold in all 50 states.
Ward’s judges gushed about the new TDI.
“Any engine that delivers 36 mpg (6.5 L/100 km) with such great drivability and affordability deserves to be 10 Best,” Editor Drew Winter writes on his TDI scoresheet.
Steve Finlay, editor of Ward’s Dealer Business magazine, calls the TDI one of the best diesels he’s ever driven. “When word gets out about this one, it may make diesels mainstream in America,” he says.
Other judges noted the TDI felt punchier than its 236 lb.-ft. (320 Nm) torque rating, and the only smoke comes not from the tailpipe but from occasionally spinning tires. Plus, the stench and clatter of old-fashioned diesels are eliminated, distant relatives from generations long gone.
Diesels already have proven to last longer than gasoline engines, including hybrids, have higher resale values and are capable of 30% better fuel economy than conventional gasoline engines.
The only drawback to some is the premium for the diesel engine, which adds about $2,000 to the Jetta’s sticker.
But, starting under $22,000, it’s less expensive than a Honda Civic Hybrid and enormously more enjoyable to drive. Add in the snappy dual-clutch DSG transmission for an extra $1,100, and the Jetta TDI still is a bargain, especially after a $1,300 income-tax credit.
Expensive diesel fuel also is bound to scare off some buyers. But a few taps on the calculator should ease those fears. Take, for instance, a typical 2.4L 4-cyl. with a combined fuel-economy rating of 23 mpg (10.2 L/100 km). With regular unleaded averaging $1.64 a gallon in the U.S., that comes to $.07 per mile traveled.
Run the same calculation for the Jetta TDI, with its combined rating of 33 mpg (7.1 L/100 km). Diesel fuel averages $2.42 a gallon in the U.S., so the cost per mile is identical. And on roadtrips, the Jetta TDI will be king of the highway.
What more could anyone want? The new Jetta TDI clears all the environmental hurdles, is tremendously rewarding to drive, reduces carbon-dioxide emissions and lessens America’s need for foreign oil.
An affordable diesel is exactly what America needs now, along with more diesel pumps.